I found this article in an e-newsletter from America's Horse (from the AQHA), and I am slightly shocked. I supposed I never really thought we would get to an age where if there was a discrepancy in the show ring, an official could simply pull out his or her "smart" device (for lack of better terminology) and go through the rule book right there with the concerned party! No more searching through page after page of a rule book that has to be tracked down and dusted off, eh?
What are your thoughts on this new digital advancement? Are you a fan of these e-reader type devices, and the availability of texts and the like, right at our fingertips?
__________________
Riding a horse is not a gentle hobby, to be picked up and laid down like a game of Solitaire. It is a grand passion. - Ralph Waldo Emerson
I work for the USEF and I LOVE not having to carry around my 3.6 pound USEF rule book! However, I also like having a hard copy for backup, to study and notate in as the rules are frequently addended and I am not always in a location/situation where electronic devices are suitable or signal strong (many equine event facilities are fairly remote, offering a poor to non-existent signal). I like, too, when a discrepancy arises, I can haul out the ol' hard copy, present the rule in live, touchable print and know that the discrepancy/discussion is pretty much clarified, accepted and over. My primary reason for maintaining use of my hardcopy is the no-battery requirement : )
No pun intended, really! but the hard copy seems to carry more weight in the moment in the event of a protest/greivance/question
-- Edited by justice on Thursday 24th of March 2011 12:35:40 PM
__________________
"....there is no normal life, Wyatt, there's just life..."
I'm with Justice on this one. Add to that the fact that I have my Canadian rulebooks (yes, there are separate rulebooks for different disciplines) tabbed with stickies and post-its, and highlighted here and there throughout.
I generally find that people trust the hard copy more than the digital version - maybe it's just digital paranoia, but the hard copy gets me farther under fire!
However, I keep the latest digital version on my computer at home, and find the "search" function incredibly useful!
You both make excellent points! I would think battery/signal requirements would be a large problem as far as digital rulebooks go. I do like that the hard copy does in fact seem to say, "look, this is copyrighted, in print, on this date, so I have truthful evidence of what is right!" or something like that. Also helpful for studying at home, as digital screens are the reason I have glasses (grrr!), so they're probably a bit easier on the eyes and physically able to be highlighted. I like db's idea of the "search" function, though! ;)
Anyone else have any thoughts? :)
__________________
Riding a horse is not a gentle hobby, to be picked up and laid down like a game of Solitaire. It is a grand passion. - Ralph Waldo Emerson
One other point would be the rain factr out on course but that kinda sx either way.. The book is a tad more durable, definitely cheaper to replace tho : )
-- Edited by justice on Thursday 24th of March 2011 02:16:32 PM
__________________
"....there is no normal life, Wyatt, there's just life..."
That's a great point, as well ;) Also not a big deal if you leave it in the truck (don't have to worry if it gets stolen, as it's a lot cheaper to replace as you said).
__________________
Riding a horse is not a gentle hobby, to be picked up and laid down like a game of Solitaire. It is a grand passion. - Ralph Waldo Emerson
I think devices are a fabulous idea and a huge help in efficiency for a show secretary or someone stationary but out on course, in mobile positions and when the bottom line is called for, the book wins for me. Where I am techno-moron to begin with, it takes me even longer to navigate on a device than it does for me to look it up anyway : )
__________________
"....there is no normal life, Wyatt, there's just life..."